How can everybody get this wrong?

Published 11/9/06

Argh! I keep seeing this — news articles that say the GOP gets control of the Senate if Allen somehow wins Virginia. From USA Today, for example:

If Allen prevailed in a vote challenge, the houses would be split between the parties.

No no no no no!

No!

If Allen prevailed, the Senate would be split 50-50. (The two independents have both said they’ll canvas with the Dems.) Yes, yes, in a tie vote the vice president gets to cast the tiebreaker, and obviously Cheney is a Republican.

But that’s only when votes come up and come to a tie. When it comes to the more important things, e.g., committee chairs, the Senate is tied. Tied.

And that hasn’t happened since (as I mentioned earlier) 1881.

There are no rules for how committees should be handled in a tie, because political parties are outside the Constitution. Would each committee have a split leadership? Would the committees themselves be split, some to the Dems and some to the Reps? No one knows. And — if Allen actually had a chance at winning — it would be an incredibly important question.

So someone has to tell these writers and editors to check their history and get a better read on what a tied Senate means. Grr.

Add to del.icio.us Digg it! Add to Technorati Add to Furl Add to reddit Stumble it!

The Fray


Scott Aaron says:

Wasn’t the Senate tied after the 2000 election as well? It was 50-50 until Jeffords defected.

November 9th, 2006 at 3:39 PM

Andrew says:

Yer right, and I missed it because it only lasted a few months — from January to May 2001. During that time, the committees were divided between the Dems and GOP, with the GOP getting to head the more-significant ones, thanks to Cheney’s power as tie-breaker.

November 9th, 2006 at 3:46 PM

gnomic says:

Thankfully, its a moot point. Webb will go to the senate, and Allen will find a job torturing small animals.

November 9th, 2006 at 8:00 PM

Weigh in

Yer name:

Yer e-mail (to be notified of responses or I can respond privately -- never ever shared):

Yer Web site (if you like):

What you have to say (Be civil, or it might be removed; comments with links
might be held for moderation, just so you know):




Site created with

and


Blog run by