Wanna be scared?

Published 6/25/07

Seriously. If nonsense like the never-could-work liquid-bomb plot got you nervous, you probably don’t want to read “Butterflies and Beverages,” the winner of Bruce Schneier’s “movie-plot threat contest.”

Your goal: invent a terrorist plot to hijack or blow up an airplane with a commonly carried item as a key component. The component should be so critical to the plot that the TSA will have no choice but to ban the item once the plot is uncovered. I want to see a plot horrific and ridiculous, but just plausible enough to take seriously.

Make the TSA ban wristwatches. Or laptop computers. Or polyester. Or zippers over three inches long. You get the idea.

The winner, by Ron Phillips, is pretty darned impressive… especially after you do a quick Froogle search to see how cheap and easy it would be to do.

Happy flying.

Add to del.icio.us Digg it! Add to Technorati Add to Furl Add to reddit Stumble it!

The Fray


greyrat says:

Heh. Yeah. It looks like gnomic was right (as he often is) a few articles ago. Well, I’ve got almost 50,000 miles to spend, and we’re flying this weekend too. Wish me luck.

June 26th, 2007 at 7:51 AM

Leland says:

Long ago (pre Sept. 11th) I spoke to a secret service agent that said, “We cringe every time Tom Clancy comes out with a new book in the Jack Ryan series.”

And as she said, “There is no way we can protect against everything. We do the best we can to cover all our bases. However no matter how much we seep and secure the area, there is always the chance that something unforeseen will get through our defenses.”

June 26th, 2007 at 3:47 PM

gnomic says:

From popsci.typepad.com article “The Amazing Rusting Aluminum”:

Quote,

Findings: Rust can hold an airplane together or dissolve it to bits.
Element: Aluminum
Project: Destroying it
Time: 1 hour
Dabbler | | | | | Master

“Unless you are a representative of a national meteorological bureau licensed to carry a barometer (and odds are you’re not), bringing mercury onboard an airplane is strictly forbidden. Why? If it got loose, it could rust the plane to pieces before it had a chance to land. You see, airplanes are made of aluminum, and aluminum is highly unstable.

“Wait, isn’t one of the great things about aluminum that, unlike iron, it doesn’t rust? Am I talking about the same aluminum? Yes! Your aluminum pot is made of a highly reactive chemical. It simply has a trick that lets it disguise itself as a corrosion-resistant metal.

“When iron rusts, it forms iron oxide—a reddish, powdery substance that quickly flakes off to expose fresh metal, which immediately begins to rust, and so on until your muffler falls off.

“But when aluminum rusts, it forms aluminum oxide, an entirely different animal. In crystal form, aluminum oxide is called corundum, sapphire or ruby (depending on the color), and it is among the hardest substances known. If you wanted to design a strong, scratchproof coating to put on a metal, few things other than diamond would be better than aluminum oxide.

“By rusting, aluminum is forming a protective coating that’s chemically identical to sapphire—transparent, impervious to air and many chemicals, and able to protect the surface from further rusting: As soon as a microscopically thin layer has formed, the rusting stops. (“Anodized” aluminum has been treated with acid and electricity to force it to grow an extra-thick layer of rust, because the more you have on the surface, the stronger and more scratch-resistant it is.)

“This invisible barrier forms so quickly that aluminum seems, even in molten form, to be an inert metal. But this illusion can be shattered with aluminum’s archenemy, mercury.

“Applied to aluminum’s surface, mercury will infiltrate the metal and disrupt its protective coating, allowing it to “rust” (in the more destructive sense) continuously by preventing a new layer of oxide from forming. The aluminum I-beam below rusted half away in a few hours, something that would have taken an iron beam years.

“I’ve heard that during World War II, commandos were sent deep into German territory to smear mercury paste on aircraft to make them inexplicably fall apart. Whether the story is true or not, the sabotage would have worked. The few-micron-thick layer of aluminum oxide is the only thing holding an airplane together. Think about that the next time you’re flying. Or maybe it’s better if you don’t.”

June 29th, 2007 at 10:36 AM

Blah, Blah, Blahg - Techie, security, political, and other useless miscellany » A hypothetical airline terrorist attack that is actually feasible - movie theater security contest says:

[...] really, exceptionally crazy thing - this threat is easier to pull off and more feasible (thanks to Andrew Kantor for that quick link) than last year’s improbable liquid-explosive-to-bring-down-planes foiled plot in England. To [...]

August 25th, 2007 at 1:44 AM

Weigh in

Yer name:

Yer e-mail (to be notified of responses or I can respond privately -- never ever shared):

Yer Web site (if you like):

What you have to say (Be civil, or it might be removed; comments with links
might be held for moderation, just so you know):




Site created with

and


Blog run by