Why Bill Richardson is the Democrat’s best hope for 2008

Published 11/30/07

People who think about these things recognize that senators just don’t become president. The last two sitting senators were Warren Harding (1921) and JFK (1961). Maybe it’s the perceived lack of experience, or maybe it’s the easy access to voting records as fodder for attack ads. For whatever reason, senators don’t become president.

Oh, and neither do representatives; James Garfield (1881) is the only sitting member of the House to be elected president.

Who does? Governors and vice presidents.

So let’s look at the current crop of candidates. (Well, viable ones. The whole list is pretty long.)

On the Dems’ side:

Biden — sitting senator
Clinton — sitting senator
Dodd — sitting senator
Edwards — lawyer (former senator)
Gravel — lecturer
Kucinich — sitting representative
Obama — sitting senator
Richardson — governor (N.M.)

On the Repubs’ side:

Giuliani — lawyer (former mayor)
Huckabee — minister (former governor)
Hunter — sitting representative
Keyes — author
McCain — sitting senator
Paul — sitting representative
Romney — businessman (former governor)
Tancredo — sitting representative
Thompson — actor (former senator)

Which means that, if you’re concerned about the party winning more than the particular candidate, Bill Richardson is your best bet on the Democratic ticket, followed by Edwards and Gravel. On the GOP ticket, Romney is your best bet, followed by Giuliani, Thomson, Huckabee and Keyes.

This is good news for the GOP because there are more non-senators and -representatives on its side. On the other hand, if Richardson gets the Democrat’s nod, history hints he can beat anyone on the Repub ticket.

Add to del.icio.us Digg it! Add to Technorati Add to Furl Add to reddit Stumble it!

The Fray


Gnomic says:

Correction! You might want to check out Huckabee’s day job: Governor of Arkansaw.

Yes, its still a state.

November 30th, 2007 at 6:41 PM

Andrew says:

Sorry, but we do have some wonderful consolation prizes for ya — he’s former gov of Arkansas.

November 30th, 2007 at 6:45 PM

Gnomic says:

OK.. but that counts. Let’s be fair to the evil GOPs. Lying is thier strength, not yours.

November 30th, 2007 at 6:49 PM

Gnomic says:

Oh. never mind.

November 30th, 2007 at 6:49 PM

RagManX says:

I was just discussing today with a conservative family member how pitiful the entire crop of candidates is. I don’t have a real liking to any of the candidates on either side. Seems we have to go back about 20 years to find a decent number of candidates (in my not so humble opinion), but none of the good ones managed to win then. WTF?

December 2nd, 2007 at 2:10 AM

Andrew says:

RagManX, I am so with you. It’s the culture of mediocrity we live in these days. Desperate not to offend anyone for any reason (by, say, taking a stand not approved by their respective parties), the candidates can be nothing but bland.

Ah, for the days of big ideas and real plans — and a country that appreciated them.

December 2nd, 2007 at 2:26 PM

Gnomic says:

I gotta agree with you Andrew. JFK started thee Vietnam war, failed at the Bay of Pigs, almost caused WW III and what do we remember him for (besides getting shot)? Starting the Space Race that put a man on the moom.

America SO lacks for competant leadership.

December 2nd, 2007 at 7:24 PM

Kortnii Kerello says:

yeah i thought this waa going to be the first year i actually wanted to vote. whats theu use? i dont like any of the people on either side? i really thought this was the year…nope, better luck next time.

December 3rd, 2007 at 10:27 AM

Kortnii Kerello says:

sorry for the typos, i am dyslexic and half asleep at my desk…..but really, when is the next election after this one? then i’ll care who wins.

December 3rd, 2007 at 10:29 AM

Gnomic says:

There hasn’t been a candidate I’ve liked enought to send money to my entire voting life (starting with the Carter election as I remember). Don’t get your hopes up. The system isn’t designed to elet the best candidate, its designed to pick the least worst one.

And it fails even that low bar from time to time.

December 3rd, 2007 at 1:03 PM

Gnomic says:

I keep seeing the following swiftboat ad on your google ad bar:

“Barack Obama Exposed”
A Free special report on the real Barack Obama - get your copy today!
http://www.(sub)HumanEvents.scum (edited)

Don’t you just love thie riech wingnuts?

December 3rd, 2007 at 1:15 PM

Randy says:

It’s so good to hear that others agree with me on how pitiful candidates are. Sorry to use my gaming name (RagManX) above when I posted. Sometimes forget who I present as my ID when posting to others’ sites.

And Gnomic, I think that’s the brightest comment on the state of elections I’ve ever heard: “The system isn’t designed to elet the best candidate, its designed to pick the least worst one.” Brilliant.

December 4th, 2007 at 2:18 PM

Weigh in

Yer name:

Yer e-mail (to be notified of responses or I can respond privately -- never ever shared):

Yer Web site (if you like):

What you have to say (Be civil, or it might be removed; comments with links
might be held for moderation, just so you know):




Site created with

and


Blog run by